A Constant Heart by Siri L. Mitchell
My review
rating: 3 of 5 stars
I give this book three out of five stars, but in a split manner. If I were to rate the book solely upon my enjoyment and escape into it's historical aspects, it would be two stars; yet if I were to rate this book on the detail and descriptions of this historical journey at hand it would four stars. Thus, I settle at three. Starting out reading this book, I was quite distraught and not at all drawn in. The cover is gorgeous and the summary sounds interesting, but in the reading I was just not there. I searched the internet for some reviews to find what others might have thought and was shocked to find all but poor reviews, minus one that only praised the author and said nothing about the book.
It is my understanding that this is the first historical from this author and although I hear her chick-lit is to die for her historical is lacking. That is not all together necessarily a full fact. The entire novel is full to the brim of historical details and facts that are painted in an array of images that could show any reader what the years of the mid-sixteenth century would appear to be. The descriptions of the clothes, the places, the people all are fascinating and plenty enough true to fact. I would highly suggest this book as a supplemental reading to be added to someone studying the Elizabethan age and wanting to find a further glance in the era.
Where I do not find my joy is in the personalities and partially the writing. The story is two from two different characters' POV and switches back and forth quite drastically without any warning and sometimes it is difficult to interpret who speaks. Other than that it is the personalities of the characters that are quite drab. I kept thinking to myself of the grey skies of London, and that is quite how I felt about this story. The idea is good and could be a fabulous book if made longer with more depth to the persons involved. But reading this story was quite painful. There was no joy only sadness and I felt it with every turn of the page. I could not interpret or assume how things would turn out and in that way they were quite a mystery. Yet in the context of day by day happens I felt quite like screaming at the insolence and blindness by how these characters lived.
Some have said that this was a very thinly veiled attempt at criticizing and lecturing people of today's society with beauty attempts, and although I can see that opinion in a manner, I would not call this a poor attempt. The story can relate and does bring to light some great value on the harsh truths that are known of women living in such a stage devoted to such a cause that is beyond their owns well-being. Yet it does it in an elegant and educational manner.
With all that said. I would not suggest this book as a light heart-ed Christian Historical Fiction to escape into the lives of those in a courtier of Elizabeth I. It is just not quite in that category. By most standards it is not a Christian Fiction as God is not mentioned in much reverence or detail nor is his role at all hinted to more than any secular novel. However, as a book for historical and educational value, I could easily suggest and see this being read and used for vast discussions and open minds and curiosity to know more about British history. So as confusing as this must sound, it solely depends upon why you wish to read this story as to whether or not you would enjoy it. That is up to you.
View all my reviews.
Saturday, September 27, 2008
A Constant Heart by Siri Mitchell: a thoughtful review
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Authors I Like...
- Amanda Cabot
- Beverly Lewis
- BJ Hoff
- Bodie & Brock Thoene
- Brandilyn Collins
- Bryan Davis
- Chris Coppernoll
- Cindy Woodsmall
- Deanna Raybourn
- Deeanne Gist
- Denise Hunter
- Diann Mills
- Donita K. Paul
- Donna Fleisher
- Elizabeth Musser
- Elsa Watson
- Francine Rivers
- Ginger Garrett
- James David Jordan
- James Scott Bell
- Jane Kirkpatrick
- Janette Oke
- Janice Thompson
- Jennier Holm
- Jerry B Jenkins
- Judith Miller
- Julie Klassen
- Julie Lessman
- Karen Ball
- Karen Kingsbury
- Kathleen Y'Barbo
- Kaye Dacus
- Kristen Heitzmann
- Kristin Billerbeck
- Lauraine Snelling
- Lawana Blackwell
- Linda Windsor
- Lisa Samson
- Lisa Tawn Bergren
- Liz Curtis Higgs
- Lori Copeland
- M.L. (MaryLu) Tyndall
- Maggie Brendan
- Mary Connealy
- Mary Higgins Clark
- Melanie Jeschke
- Melanie Wells
- Melody Carlson
- Michelle Moran
- Michelle Sutton
- Nancy Moser
- Rebeca Seitz
- Rene Gutteridge
- Rita Gerlach
- Sarah Sundin
- Sharon Hinck
- Shaunti Feldhahn
- Shelley Shepard Gray
- Stephanie Grace Whitson
- Stephen Lawhead
- Susan May Warren
- T.L. (Tracy) Higley
- Tamera Alexander
- Tim Lahaye
- Tracie Peterson
- Vickie McDonough
- Virginia (Ginny) Smith
Blog Archive
-
▼
2008
(569)
-
▼
September
(97)
- GIVEAWAY: One Perfect Day
- The Berenstain Bears Go to Sunday School: a review
- The Berenstain Bears and the Golden Rule: a review
- The Rook by Steven James (Press Release)
- FIRST: The Personifid Invasion (book #2) by R.E. B...
- Lady of Milkweed Manor by Julie Klassen: a high re...
- WINNERS!!!
- CFBA: John 3:16 by Nancy Moser
- A Beautiful Fall by Chris Coppernoll COMING SOON!
- FIRST: The Miracle Girls by Anne Dayton and May V...
- GIVEAWAYS!!
- FIRST: Hero, Second Class by Mitchell Bonds
- Losing God by Matt Rogers
- A Constant Heart by Siri Mitchell: a thoughtful re...
- FIRST: Summa Elvetica by Theodore Beale
- Update on the House
- About Me meme
- How to Get Your Husband to Listen to You by Nancy ...
- Trailer: Rachel's Secret by BJ Hoff
- FIRST: Sunset by Karen Kingsbury
- Diamond Duo by Marcia Gruver
- Heartsong Presents Mysteries: Murder on the Ol' Bu...
- I've been redesigned!
- Button and a Makeover
- Around the World in 80 Dates & Blessed Are the Med...
- Author of the Month at A Peek At My Bookshelf
- Trailer: The Trophy Chase Trilogy by George Bryan ...
- CSFF Blog Tour: Marcher Lord Press Day 3
- When the Soul Mends (book #3) by Cindy Woodsmall: ...
- When the Morning Comes (book #2) by Cindy Woodsmall
- When the Heart Cries (book #1) by Cindy Woodsmall
- CFBA: When the Soul Mends by Cindy Woodsmall
- Update on the House
- Brisingr by Christopher Paolini
- Trailer: White Christmas Pie by Wanda Brunstetter
- CSFF Blog Tour: Marcher Lord Press Day 2
- FIRST: White Christmas Pie by Wanda Brunstetter
- The Lucky One by Nicholas Sparks
- Ripple Effect by Paul McCusker
- Trailer: Field of Blood by Eric Wilson
- Q&A with Michelle Moran, bestselling author of "Ne...
- CSFF Blog Tour: Marcher Lord Press Day 1
- CFBA: Faking Grace by Tamera Leigh
- Fall Into Reading 2008
- Jessie by Lori Wick: a review
- FIRST & GIVEAWAYS: It's All About Us & The Fruit o...
- Mary's First Thanksgiving by Kathy-jo Wargin and I...
- My Plans for the Day - - CONCERT!!! WOOHOO!!!
- My Affiliations
- The Heretic Queen by Michelle Moran: a review
- WINNER & prayer
- Children's Bible: The Jesus Storybook Bible by Sal...
- Liberty Letters: Attack at Pearl Harbor by Nancy L...
- Liberty Letters: Adventures in Jamestown by Nancy ...
- Children's Bible: Tiny Bear's Bible by Sally Lloyd...
- The Berenstain Bears and the Golden Rule
- The Berenstain Bears Go to Sunday School!!!!!
- P Is for Pumpkin by Kathy-jo Wargin and Illus. YaW...
- Mary's First Thanksgiving by Kathy-jo Wargin and I...
- Why I Love Blogging
- FIRST & GIVEAWAY: It's All About Us by Shelley Adina
- Update on the House
- Woah, hiya God...
- GIVEAWAY: The Miracle Girls by Anne Dayton & May V...
- Trailer: Appalosa
- CFBA: The Bride Bargain by Kelly Eileen Hake
- FIRST: Pure by Rebecca St. James (a devotional)
- FIRST: Isolation by Travis Thrasher
- Stupid Banks
- Fwd: New Suspense Novel from Travis Thrasher: ISOL...
- In Stores Today! The Heretic Queen by Michelle Moran
- Library Presentation
- A Christian Guid to Conscience: Knowing Right from...
- Trailer: Isolation
- Old Milton Country Fair
- CFBA & GIVEAWAY: Isolation by Travis Thrasher
- FIRST: When Answers Aren't Enough by Matt Rogers: ...
- Admission by Travis Thrasher: a short review
- Trailers: B&H T.L. Higley (A Seven Wonders Novel, ...
- Friends of the Library Presentation
- FIRST: First Place 4 Health by Carole Lewis
- Goodbye Hollywood Nobody by Lisa Samson: a review
- CFBA: In the Shadow of Lions by Ginger Garrett
- FIRST: A Passion Redeemed by Julie Lessman
- Book Trailers
- CFBA Wounded by Claudia Mair Burney
- Wedding Bell Blues by Linda Windsor: a review
- Guest Review: A Proper Pursuit by Lynn Austin
- FIRST: That's Not (Exactly) Amore by Tracey Bateman
- Book Blogs
- Fireproof the movie
- Up Pops the Devil by Angela Benson
- Just As I Am by Virginia Smith: a review
- City of the Dead by T.L. Higley: a trailer
- Motiv8 COMING SOON!
- Back to Life by Kristin Billerbeck: a review
- FIRST: The Summer the Wind Whispered My Name by Do...
-
▼
September
(97)
3 comments and creative thoughts:
I've been thinking about getting this book but after having read your review I don't think I'll rush out and get it. It doesn't sound like it's something I would like. So thanks for the review. :)
I loved it! Ha! I loved Marget and didn't feel sermonized to at all. Oh well, different strokes for different folks, I think Siri is a wonderfully gifted writer.
Now wait a minute! I did not say "sermonized" but I do know that I have read other reviews that said that. I enjoyed the book, did not love it. I think that it is a wonderful historical addition to make the facts a little more interesting while learning about that time, but I do not find it up there with other historical fictions that I can read to escape into their world. I do not want to be in her world, it is harder than my own. Does that make sense??
Post a Comment